New York Times, AP Retract False Claims on Intel Report on Russia Hacking

Jason Ditz Posted onJuly 1, 2017

Among the most oft-repeated claims of the entire Russia election hacking scandal is that of absolute unanimity among US intelligence agencies, with media and politicians regularly claiming that “all 17 US intelligence agencies have agreed that Russia tried to in....” It’s not true.

Nearly a year into the hacking scandal, both the New York Times and the Associated Press are finally copping to the fact that this allegation is untrue, and retracting it outright. The AP confirmed falsely making the claim in at least four distinct articles, most recently on Thursday.

What actually happened? The Director of National Intelligence made the allegation, claiming it was based on information from three US agencies, the CIA, FBI, and NSA. The Director of National Intelligence nominally represents all 17 intelligence agencies, and that was quickly and incorrectly extrapolated into all 17 agencies being in consensus.

In practice, however, the DNI is an increasingly politicized office, and their publications aren’t necessarily in line with actual reality, let alone proof of a consensus among the intelligence agencies. Indications are that the overwhelming majority of the US intelligence agencies were never even involved in assessing the Russia hacks.

Nor would they be expected to be. It would be bizarre if the Pentagon’s intelligence agency, for example, was probing US elections, or if the National Reconnaissance Office, which operates spy satellites looking for missile launches, was chiming in on the Trump Campaign.

It sounded better, particularly for those trying to make this into a bigger scandal, however, to claim that “all 17” US intelligence agencies had agreed on the narrative, because this would give the impression that it’s indisputable fact, as opposed to a heavily politically-motivated assertion backed up by limited circumstantial evidence dug up by a couple of US spy agencies.

Last 5 posts by Jason Ditz

• China Demands US Halt $1.42 Billion Arms Sale to Taiwan - June 30th, 2017
• Despite Blockade, Saudi Arabia, UAE, and Qatar Share Oil Tankers - June 30th, 2017
• As ISIS Wanes, New Wars Threaten to Emerge in Syria - June 30th, 2017
• UN: Nearly 500,000 Syrians Returned Home This Year - June 30th, 2017
• Syrian Kurds Plan to Attack Turkish-Held Border Areas - June 30th, 2017

http://news.antiwar.com/2017/07/01/new-york-times-ap-retract-false-...

Author: Jason Ditz

Jason Ditz is news editor of Antiwar.com. View all posts by Jason Ditz